Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?
November 18, 2017, 12:00:42 pm

Login with username, password and session length
Search:     Advanced search
Savage: XR is a new patch for Savage, created by the Newerth.com staff. The XR1.1 Client is out now! Download it now!
188621 Posts in 10884 Topics by 17943 Members
Latest Member: Yustus123321
* Home Forum Wiki Help Search Login Register
  Show Posts
Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 139
1  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth (SIGN-UP & POSTGAME) on: September 10, 2010, 12:08:52 pm
Gonna pass on that one, I'm way too busy these days. Not gonna play another semi-inactive game Undecided
2  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth (SIGN-UP & POSTGAME) on: September 09, 2010, 10:35:04 pm
Don't laugh! Next game you'll get feathers for weapons!
3  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth (SIGN-UP & POSTGAME) on: September 09, 2010, 10:31:31 pm
Speaking of which, I did honestly wonder how much all the (honestly) declared human roles helped the beasts. I don't know at what rate the townies usually reveal their roles in mafia games, but I felt it helped us a lot predicting people's actions and viable nightly murder targets.

Oh, and something else random: did Rolex actually get the "Relox" because of his nick? Cheesy (Tjens suggested this on day 5)
4  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth (SIGN-UP) on: September 09, 2010, 10:02:38 pm
I do think the roles were well chosen and picked though; just the right amount of dangerousness in each to not let these 20 mafia newbs run into complete chaos Grin
(imagine... if there would have been human roles which could kill every or even just every other night...)
5  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth (SIGN-UP) on: September 09, 2010, 10:00:26 pm
Ooooh, land mine prototypes >.<

We scouted that and thought you might be a "paranoid granny" kinda role which kills anyone visiting her at night... and then it's actually an odd way of putting a beast detection ability, which even turns out to be broken Angry
6  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth (SIGN-UP) on: September 09, 2010, 09:48:24 pm
Oh yeah, laughed hard when they believed Beard!'s ridiculous Ophelia story Cheesy

Nice game indeed, Daemon, thanks!


Really should've been more active throughout the days next time, it was a pain talking myself out of that and act all "i'm just careful, nothing more!"
7  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth (SIGN-UP) on: September 09, 2010, 09:42:57 pm
Yeeeah, sorry, had trouble deciding whether to vote for Fat-Tony. I considered it too risky; the way day 8 went it would've been super-easy to have a 100% safe win the next day even without lynching Fat-Tony. I guess I want to know now whom Tjens would have immobilized on night 8 Tongue

Actually we could've had a 100% safe win today if we just agreed upon all 3 voting on Tjens in the last 5 minutes of the day; I was mad at myself all day for not thinking of that before the day started lol.
Anyway, seems the victory conditions played out way better for us than we thought. We didn't even have to bother with day 8 at all Undecided
8  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth (SIGN-UP) on: September 09, 2010, 09:30:41 pm
Actually thought humans were still in it if Tjens just immobilized the correct person during night 8..

Not gonna complain though lol Evil


Btw, your final post does not list Happy, Daemon. [for all I knew he could possibly still have had a demopack and killed a beast]
9  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth - Day 8 (Sept 9th, 21 NT) on: September 09, 2010, 08:49:00 pm
Wth is going on now? Couldn't you two have had this discussion like.. 2 hours earlier?! This is just calling for snap judgements... -.-

10 minutes left...
10  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth - Day 8 (Sept 9th, 21 NT) on: September 09, 2010, 08:24:12 pm
Hmm.. 35 minutes left and we still haven't found a beast to lynch, this is not good Undecided
11  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth - Day 8 (Sept 9th, 21 NT) on: September 08, 2010, 03:02:04 pm
Yeeeah, even if he is a beast, why wouldn't he just copy Unsafe's statement now? Or did he actually vote on a day preceded by a night during which you drugged him? If not, I don't think we'll convinct a beast with this.

And even then, you could be just a beast making your role up as it fits to incriminate someone! Looking at this list, it seems there also were multiple instances of humans voting after being drugged: (unless the list you gave us is completely rubbish...)
Night 1: Hakugei
Night 2: Mind
Night 3: Unsafe
Night 4: Didn't drug anyone
Night 5: Dervun
Night 6: Mefix
Night 7: Didn't drug anyone

Double checking IgorS

Bolding the inconsistencies:
Haku(Beast) voted on day 2
Mind(Human) voted on day 3
Unsafe(Human) couldnt vote ln day 4:
My email says I can't vote today. Just wanted to put this out in the open now, so there's no more confusion. Anywho, this is getting bad, if we don't lynch a beast now, we pretty much gonna be 50/50 on races and that kinda makes humans the loser team.
No info on day 5
Dervun(Human) voted on day 6
Mefix(Human) could not vote on day 7
No info on day 8

2 cases checks out, 3 dont.
I call bs.
12  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth - Day 8 (Sept 9th, 21 NT) on: September 07, 2010, 04:30:57 pm
Thank you Smiley

F1 Notausgang

Okay, so I'm a secret agent, though in fact more of a private investigator, since I sadly do not have the license to kill. I can secretly follow someone around at night and get to know where they went (but not what they do if they enter a person's room).
I'll also provide the list of who I followed what night since there's really no reason not to at this point:
  • Night 1: I followed Mind to Hakugei's room.
  • Night 2: I waited around Mchief's room, but he did not leave.
  • Night 3: I followed Fat-Tony to Unsafe's room.
  • Night 4 & 5: I was not paying enough attention to the game and failed to send my targets in time Sad
  • Night 6: I observed Unsafe standing in front of his room all night (lol @ that description of him being immobilized/snared Cheesy)
  • Night 7: I followed Mefix to Happy's room.

F2 Notausgang

Curious to see whether someone else can make some use of it. This data alone is fairly useless to me.
13  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth - Day 8 (Sept 9th, 21 NT) on: September 07, 2010, 04:05:05 pm
Hmm.. good idea! That completely circumvents the problem Mefix mentioned - the three beasts hopping on to insta-lynch me.
I'll need a second vote though; would you be so kind, IgorS?
14  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth - Day 8 (Sept 9th, 21 NT) on: September 07, 2010, 03:52:01 pm
Even more, Faun was bandwagon-ing Moxy on day 1, he was voting against WinterFresh on day 2, he lynched mind on day 3 (?), (dunno about days 4/5/6), he lynched UnSaFe on day 7.. A perfect beast spotted.

(Un)fortunately - there were no beasts in the room of Faun tonight as well -- Faun(7).. So I guess he's human after all. :/
Meh, way to be anticlimactic.

And yes, you are probably right about the beast count, should be 3 now; if it's 4 now we're already doomed.

As for declaring my role, the game is close enough to the end that it doesn't really help hiding it anymore. As stated before I deem it a rather useless one; beasts would probably see me as harmless after I declare it, but apparently I couldn't get them to consider me as target so far anyway. Maybe I needed to be louder and more accusing; maybe it was just that so many other people have revealed their more dangerous roles. (I still think having had so many roles be declared so early hurt us a lot)

As for "today", we absolutely must make sure to lynch a beast today. Not lynching at all probably will still give us another day (4 humans, 3 beasts the next day), but we definitely should try our best to identify and get rid of a beast, I think.
15  Off Topic / Mafia (play-by-post game) / Re: Mafia 1 - Newerth - Day 8 (Sept 9th, 21 NT) on: September 06, 2010, 09:15:53 pm
Oh wow, didn't realize she was a woman. Any other women here?... well so much for reproduction in this tribe... Undecided Rolleyes

Even though it only reads "Traitor Worker's Whore", I'm assuming (s)he counted as a human as well (or are there 3 parties involved?!). That leaves 8 people alive out of which 3-5 are beasts (assuming there were 6-8 in total at the start). Actually it can't be 5 or Daemon would have had to declare beast victory already; so 3-4 left, and only 4-5 humans. No more wrong moves now...
Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 139
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.20 | SMF © 2006-2007, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!
Page created in 0.036 seconds with 18 queries.